Law Offices of Donald J. Matson, PC.
Law Offices of Donald J. Matson, PC.

Call For A Free Consultation
(626) 600-3437

Sentencing Guidelines

  • By: Donald J. Matson, Esq.
  • Published: October 2, 2024
Close-up of a judge using a gavel, symbolizing the enforcement of Sentencing Guidelines in a courtroom

Federal Sentencing Guidelines

Federal sentencing guidelines are like the rulebook that judges use to determine fair and consistent sentences for individuals and organizations convicted of serious crimes in the U.S. federal court system. Established by the United States Sentencing Commission, these guidelines ensure that similar offenses receive similar punishments, avoiding the wild swings that can happen without a standardized system.

Key Elements

Now, let’s quickly delve into fundamental aspects of federal sentencing guidelines. Here, I’ll outline key elements that shape these guidelines and their application in the judicial process.

Offense Level

Every crime is assigned a base offense level, which is a starting point for sentencing. This level can be adjusted depending on the specifics of the case. For instance, if a crime caused significant harm or if the defendant played a major role in the offense, the offense level might be increased.

Criminal History Category

Defendants are placed into categories based on their prior criminal records. The more extensive the criminal history, the higher the category, which means a harsher sentence. It’s a way to ensure that repeat offenders face stiffer penalties.

Adjustments

Adjustments are where things get a bit nuanced. For example, if a defendant accepts responsibility for their actions, they might receive a reduction in their offense level. Conversely, if they obstruct justice, their offense level could go up. 

The Sentencing Table

This is where the offense level and criminal history category come together. Picture a grid where you match the offense level on one axis with the criminal history category on the other. The point where they intersect gives you a range of months for the sentence, providing a low and high end. Judges use this range to determine the appropriate sentence.

Departures

In some cases, judges can depart from the guidelines. If there are unique circumstances—either aggravating or mitigating—that the guidelines don’t fully account for, the judge has the discretion to adjust the sentence accordingly.

Mandatory Minimums

Certain federal crimes come with mandatory minimum sentences. These set the minimum amount of time a defendant must serve, no matter what the guidelines might suggest. It’s a floor that judges can’t go below.

These guidelines are not mandatory but instead advisory. Judges generally follow them, but they have the flexibility to deviate if the situation warrants it. Their purpose is to promote fairness and consistency across the federal criminal justice system, ensuring sentences are proportional to the crime with a thorough understanding of the defendant’s background. One of the stated aims is to reduce disparities and bring a sense of uniformity to sentencing practices.

Sentencing Outcomes In Federal Cases

Sentencing outcomes in federal cases can vary widely depending on the nature of the crime, your criminal history, and other factors. Possible sentencing outcomes include:

Incarceration

The most common outcome is incarceration, where you are sentenced to a term of imprisonment in a federal facility. The length of the sentence depends on the severity of the offense and the sentencing guidelines.

Probation

Instead of prison, you might be placed on supervised probation. This comes with strict conditions, and any violation can result in imprisonment. Probation allows you to live in the community while being monitored closely.

Fines

You may be ordered to pay fines. The amount varies based on the offense and your ability to pay. Fines serve as both punishment and a deterrent.

Restitution

Restitution requires you to compensate the victims of your crime for their losses. This can be ordered in addition to or instead of other forms of punishment. It aims to make the victim whole again financially.

Community Service

In some cases, you may be required to perform a certain number of hours of community service. This is often used for less severe offenses and aims to benefit the community.

Home Confinement

Instead of serving time in a federal facility, you might be confined to your home for a specified period, monitored by electronic devices. This is known as home detention or home monitoring.

Supervised Release

After serving a prison term, you might be placed under supervised release for a period, typically up to five years—maybe even longer, depending on the crime. During this time, you must comply with certain conditions or risk being sent back to prison.

Deportation

For non-citizens, deportation can be a consequence of their crime. After serving their sentence, they may be deported to their home country.

Forfeiture

You may be required to surrender assets related to the crime. This could include money, property, or other assets gained through illegal activities.

The specific sentence in any federal case is determined by the judge. The judge considers the federal sentencing guidelines, the pre-sentence investigation report, the arguments from both the prosecution and the defense, and any mitigating or aggravating factors. The goal is to arrive at a fair and just outcome that fits the crime and the circumstances of the defendant.

Mitigating the Negative Impact of a Conviction

Having an experienced attorney by your side can truly be a game-changer in a criminal defense case. They will provide you with the support, advocacy, and guidance you’ll need to make it through an incredibly challenging time. Their involvement can significantly influence the outcome and help you rebuild your life. Here are some specific ways how:

Sentencing Advocacy

One of the most fundamental ways an attorney can help is through sentencing advocacy. They will present mitigating factors to the court, advocating for a reduced sentence or alternative sentencing options such as probation, community service, or rehabilitative programs. A well-argued case can make a significant difference in the outcome.

Appeals and Post-Conviction Relief

If there were legal errors during the trial that affected the outcome, an attorney can file an appeal. They can also seek post-conviction relief, such as a motion for a new trial or a reduction in sentence. This process can be complex, but an attorney’s experience is invaluable in navigating it. Be sure to partner with a skilled attorney who won’t let a case-altering error slip through the cracks of your case.

Expungement and Record Sealing

In certain cases, an attorney can help get your criminal record expunged or sealed. This can significantly limit the impact of the conviction on future employment, housing, and other opportunities. Imagine the relief of having a perfectly clean slate!

Negotiating Plea Bargains

An attorney can also negotiate plea bargains with prosecutors to potentially reduce the charges and penalties. A skilled negotiator can turn a potentially severe sentence into something much more manageable.

Legal Advice and Guidance

Navigating the legal system is challenging, but an attorney provides invaluable support. They offer legal advice on how to comply with court requirements and understand the long-term consequences of a conviction. Their guidance can help you make informed decisions at every step.

Employment and Licensing Issues

A criminal conviction can affect professional licensing and employment. An attorney can address these issues, helping you manage any professional or licensing repercussions. They can assist in presenting your case to licensing boards or potential employers, making a significant difference in your ability to move forward.

Reducing Federal Sentences After They’re Imposed

Federal sentences can be reduced after they’re imposed, but it can happen only under very particular circumstances. Each has very specific requirements and procedures that need to be followed, underscoring the importance of having a skilled attorney on your side to navigate these complex processes.

Appeals

An appeal is one of the most common methods. If the appeal to a higher court is successful, the sentence can be reduced. This process involves arguing that there were legal errors during the trial or sentencing that warrant a different outcome.

Rule 35(b) Motion

If you were to provide substantial assistance in the investigation or prosecution of another person, the prosecution can file a Rule 35(b) motion to reduce the sentence. This cooperation must be significant and usually involves aiding in solving other crimes.

Compassionate Release

As a defendant, you may seek a reduction of your sentence due to extraordinary and compelling circumstances, such as a serious medical condition. Compassionate release is typically granted in cases where an inmate’s health is severely deteriorating, and continued incarceration would be inhumane.

Changes in Sentencing Laws

Sometimes, changes in sentencing guidelines or mandatory minimums can be applied retroactively. If such changes occur, you could be eligible for a reduced sentence. This requires a robust understanding of the law to navigate and leverage these opportunities.

Presidential Pardon or Commutation

Although rare, the President of the United States has the power to pardon someone from their federal sentence or commute their sentence, which means shortening it or converting it to a different form of punishment. This is highly unlikely unless you have a significant connection to the president or are involved in a very high-profile case.

For more information on Sentencing Guidelines, a free initial consultation is your next best step. Get the information and legal answers you are seeking by calling (626) 600-3437 today.

Copyright©2024. Law Offices of Donald J. Matson, PC. All Rights Reserved.

Accessibility Accessibility
× Accessibility Menu CTRL+U